Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Newcastle Battle Injury Woes Ahead of Tottenham

Rough Play and Chas McFarland

There's been a fair amount of talk over the last couple of days about the increased roughness of play n the ACC and college basketball in general, most of it spinning off of this N&O article. I think Ken Tysiac basically gets it right in the article with this simple fact:

Some coaches say more contact is inevitable in college basketball because the players are larger and the court has remained the same size.


Duke started this season with six players listed at 225 pounds or more. Ten years ago, the 1999-2000 Duke roster listed two players at more than 215 pounds.    

So the play's gotten rougher, and will continue that way until fouls are called. Which will generate more complaints from crowds, as long as you're calling them against the home team. It's worth noting that UNC is one of the softer playing teams in college basketball this season, both by observation, and statistically – the Heels are second only to Mississippi State in opponents' free throws attempted vs. field goals attempted. Carolina just doesn't foul.

Which brings up this little tidbit. After last night's Duke-Wake game, Duke Basketball Report has a simpler explanation for the rough style of play. Chas McFarland:

There's a reason why anger follows wherever McFarland goes: he generates it.  ESPN highlighted the flagrant hit by Gonzaga's forward Elias Harris, but didn't show the things McFarland did to provoke it. Last year, TV showed the Clemson students pummel him when he went into the stands.  It seemed outrageous, but as is so often the case with McFarland, things don't happen in a vacuum. 


Between Duke and Wake, we expect a tough, hard-fought game.  We don't expect to see the sort of junk McFarland pulls.  Consider:  as a big inside player, how often have you seen Brian Zoubek get seriously irritated by an opponent?  Tyler Hansbrough?  Deon Thompson? Dexter Strickland?  Gani Lawal? Solomon Alabi?

You can keep asking and the answer comes to one:  McFarland. Someone needs to deal with him before a game gets completely out of hand.    

I don't remember much of McFarland's play last year, but it was effective enough to get him 20 points and 9 rebounds. He finished the game with four fouls. He doesn't lead his team in fouls called per time played, falling behind two other big men on the Demon Deacons. 

Is conference play getting to rough, and is McFarland a prime example of it, or is this a case of Duke fans hating the player in front of them? I haven't seen enough to have an opinion one way or the other, but it's something to look for on Wednesday.

Comment 10 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

i like it

TH I like it. The ACC has long been a “soft” and finesse league. Then we go to the tourney and teams get drilled in the first weekend because of the toughness of other leagues and swallowing the whistles on the officials part. The league as a whole has, for the last two decades, been characterized by guys flopping and looking to the refs after contact. Watching the Big East and Big XII you don’t see these phantom falldowns or expecting foul calls. Rather you see guys finishing strong at the rim, bodying guys up on the block and an overall toughness.

I know some people will bring out the “s” or “t” word in reference to this (streetball or thug) but its just toughness. There’s a reason so many Big East teams reached the Sweet 16 and Elite 8 last season. As a league there’s a toughness gap and I’d like to see us rise to the level of the Big East and Big XII not try to bring them down to our finesse level.

ItsFELDER

by MichaelFelder on Jan 18, 2010 11:44 AM EST via mobile reply actions  

Step 1: Every conference plays like the Big East.
Step 2: ?
Step 3: College basketball is as frustrating to watch as professional basketball.

by capital L on Jan 19, 2010 6:59 AM EST up reply actions  

Big East

I see your argument made all the time. I don’t understand what is frustrating about watching Big East basketball but then again I also don’t hate the NBA as apparently every ACC fan does.

When it comes to toughness I see the difference when we get to the tourney. Maryland with Greivis was a tough team, UNC with Hansbrough was a tough team, Duke was somewhat scrappy. They won. The rest of the league was lacking and that showed itself in the first round a season ago.

Make the anti-NBA argument all you want, my point remains that early 90’s-2000 the ACC as a whole was better. And during this now 2 decade period we’ve seen basketball shift and the ACC isn’t shifting slower than the other leagues. Villanova not only out quicked Duke but they out muscled them. Michigan wasn’t better than Clemson but they out toughed the Tigers. In 2008 we saw a physical Cole Aldrich own Hansbrough, he came back the next season and righted that mistake.

ItsFELDER

by MichaelFelder on Jan 19, 2010 9:15 AM EST via mobile up reply actions  

I would prefer to advocate for other leagues to improve their officiating, rather than press for the ACC to muddy their style of play.

That’s just me though.

by capital L on Jan 19, 2010 6:28 PM EST up reply actions  

Addendum

I don’t really mind the NBA, mind you, I just don’t know if that’s the model of play that college basketball needs to emulate, seeing as how there already is a highly visible venue for that style of play—namely, the NBA.

by capital L on Jan 19, 2010 6:29 PM EST up reply actions  

agree to disagree

Agree to disagree I guess. For me I’m clouded as I’m admittedly a football first fan, one of the few UNC ones. So when I hear people say the SEC is the closest thing to NFL football or that USC is as close as it gets to the league that is a style of play and philosophy that I’d like to emulate. I’m glad Butch doesn’t run a spread, that we play an NFL scheme and that he’s actively searching for guys whose goal is to play NFL football.

So your comment about the Big East being too NBA-like and the other leagues need to officiate better and play more like ACC sounds odd to me. Granted its not the first time I’ve heard it; my UNC classmates are mostly bball nuts too. Agree to disagree we’re all hoping for as good as season as we can have.

2 weeks to signing day!

ItsFELDER

by MichaelFelder on Jan 20, 2010 11:30 AM EST via mobile up reply actions  

I’ve liked UNC’s scheduling of Rutgers over the past few seasons, exposing the team to Big East play without risking a loss, but I’d be depressed if al of college basketball went to that style. Although it appears that every conference is going to have the same number of fouls called regardless of the style of play, even Big XII refs are beginning to crack down it’s gotten so bad.

by T.H. on Jan 19, 2010 8:42 AM EST up reply actions  

It isn’t the roughness that bothers me. It is the cheap dirtiness.

I remember thinking last year how dirty and just unsportsmanlike that McFarland was.

"My team of nine guys who hit like Albert Pujols and never ever bunt just beat your team with one Shane Victorino 472 to 3."

by justincredubil02 on Jan 18, 2010 12:21 PM EST reply actions  

Tonight

The Wear Bros. are really going to have their work cut out for them tonight.

by MakhtarsMusings on Jan 20, 2010 12:59 PM EST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


Managers

Rameses_small T.H.