Carolina March: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: MLB postseason scores, schedules and blog coverage Bar-right-arrows



Can We Stop With This Unfair Home-Court Advantage Crap?

Somehow over the last week, the fact that UNC's route through the tournament goes through Raleigh and Charlotte has really begun to irk people. Chief among them Rick Pitino, in a passive-agressive sort of way:

"Tell Roy to get on a plane for the first time and let's play the game at Freedom Hall (Louisville's home building) if he feels that way," Pitino said. "I won't disagree with him, let's go to Freedom Hall and I'll admit to a home-court advantage. Go to Lexington for that matter and play at (Rupp Arena). No, I think those are mannequins dressed in powder blue. I don't think there is a home-court advantage.

"There is a very strong home-court advantage but they deserve it. That's the bottom line. They're the No. 1 seed, but to say there's no home-court advantage, that doesn't mean we don't have the ability to win. They deserve the people because they were the No. 1 team in the country."

Look, if you don't want a team's path to the Final Four to be entirely in-state, there's a simple solution - put the different sites in different states. There are - hold on, let me count - fifty of the damn things, each with quite a few stadiums. I'm pretty sure we could swing this if we want.

But this attitude of shocked surprise coming from the media is a bit much for me. I've known for months that the East Regional was in Charlotte and the opening rounds were in Raleigh? How? Because the media wouldn't shut up about it. Every Carolina-Duke game, it was mention at least a half-dozen times as the carrot being dangled in front of both teams. Every mention of the ACC standings, Raleigh and Charlotte would come up. All through the ACC Tournament, talk about Raleigh and Charlotte. And yet through all of this, no one thought it was unfair until UNC started ripping through teams like a buzzsaw. This Carolina team could have played three road games and still put up huge margins against their opponents. And should the Heels make it to San Antonio, well, I'm pretty sure there will be a fair amount of Carolina Blue in the stands there as well.

I could also do without ever hearing this stat ever again:

And for those who do not think it matters, I would invite you to explain how North Carolina is 24-1 (96 percent) in NCAA tournament games played inside the state of North Carolina and just 71-37 (66 percent) in NCAA tournament games played outside the state of North Carolina.

That's not a coincidence.

How about - and this is just me tossing this out here - because UNC's been a number one seed practically every time they've played in North Carolina[*]? Because that's how they've rewarded top seeds since they instituted seeding, by playing the opening rounds at the closest site? Have you never seen one of these tournaments before?

Again, if you really don't think this is fair, it can easily be fixed long before the season starts. But since it's only bothering you now that the stands are filled with Tar Heels, well, I'll try to get the Tiny Violin Orchestra together for you.

0 recs | Comment 4 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Footnote
The only time UNC played a tournament game in NC when they weren't the number one seed was in 1983, when as a two seed they beat James Madison before advancing to the Sweet Sixteen in Syracuse. Also, there were no seedings for the earliest tournament appearances in 1968, 1975 and 1977.

Of the twenty-five tournament games to date UNC has played in-state, 16 were first or second round games. In only three years (1968, 1982 and 1998) have the regionals been in North Carolina.

The one loss was in 1979, when the top-seeded Heels were upset in Raleigh by Pennsylvania in their first game. UNC also once had the challenge of winning a tournament game on an opponent's home court - as a two seed they beat Digger Phelps' seventh-seeded Notre Dame at Notre Dame on a last second steal. No one from Carolina complained about the game's location.

by T.H. on Mar 29, 2008 4:42 PM EDT   0 recs

You tell 'em, Dude.
I suppose it was those smatterings of UNC fans at all those away games during the season that help the team win too. Because Carolina fans are, after all, well known for being loud - standing and cheering from the opening tip until the last buzzer...

Oh, wait...these are CAROLINA fans we're talking about here. The "wine and cheese" folks, right? Yes, yes, I can see how they could put the fear of God into opposing teams; being stared at silently always bothers me too.

Sorry, please excuse my frustration with my fellow UNC fans. To be fair, they've gotten better than they were when I was in college, but there is still far too much sitting quietly and not enough cheering for my tastes. And to have to put up with that on one side and the whining from opponents about a "crowd advantage" on the other is a bit much to stand.

by CL on Mar 29, 2008 5:27 PM EDT   0 recs

Well...
I would probably agree, except Roy Williams started this by saying that playing in the state of North Carolina wasn't that big of a deal because UNC lost at home--twice--this year.  If you're going to make a ridiculous statement like that (and throw in a patented Williamsism, specifically "How in the dickens did we lose those games with a home-court advantage?") you should probably expect the opposing coach to make light of the situation.

Not saying UNC doesn't deserve the Raleigh-Charlotte route, merely pointing out that Roy Williams brought this one on himself.

We'll carry the banner high!

by TB on Mar 29, 2008 8:36 PM EDT   0 recs

On the Other Hand...
... it's not like Williams has much choice in the matter. If a reporter asks you (basically) "Do you think this will be easier than normal?" what are you supposed to do? You don't want to give the other team bulletin board material, nor do you want your own potential accomplishment diminished ahead of time. Of course you don't claim an advantage, just like you never have anything but praise for that 16th seed you play in the opening round. And UNC's record has been better on the road this season - no matter the location, they had to go out and win the game.

That being said, when your fans can do a cross-stadium chant of "Tar! Heels!" at a neutral site, well, it's a help not a hinderance.

by T.H. on Mar 30, 2008 5:06 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

As cited in the Journal of American Folkore.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

180px-purduepete_small
North Carolina Trounces Miami Football; Gnarliest Block Ever? Video
Small
North Carolina Fball Preview
Lsu_logo_small
Tastelessness?
Galagaship_small
Welcome to the new Carolina March and SB Nation
Small
UNC Fan at USC
Bucem_l_small
Must be Bobby, Bobby Blizzard that is . . .
Bucem_l_small
Former Tar Heel Dexter Reid in Trouble with Law
Small
how many wins can butch davis squeeze out
Bucem_l_small
ACC Baseball Tournament
Bucem_l_small
Leavin' Early Redux . . .

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Site Meter